The Role of an Academic Publishing Coach

academic skills grad school imposter syndrome journal articles peer-review productivity strategies Jul 26, 2023
woman taking notes at laptop; academic publishing coach, PhD, early career researcher

Hey there, PhDs and early career academics! If you're feeling overwhelmed and stuck in your research journey, I want you to know that you're not alone. We've all been there, and it's completely normal to feel the weight of imposter syndrome and the fear of rejection. But guess what? You've got this 💪, and we're here to support, encourage, and empower you. In this guide, let's delve into the world of academic publishing coaches, the unsung heroes who can transform your research dreams into published reality.

What is an Academic Publishing Coach?

In today's academic climate there is so much pressure to publish, to publish early, and to publish frequently. An academic publishing coach helps you acheive your publishing goals with less stress and in less time. 

At its core, an academic publishing coach is like having a personal mentor who knows the ins and outs of the publishing process. Picture this: someone who has been in your shoes, faced the same hurdles, and ultimately succeeded in getting their research published. They are experienced professionals with a passion for helping others, and they're dedicated to making your publishing journey smoother, less intimidating, and, most importantly, successful. 

An academic publishing coach is not just a service provider; they are your cheerleader, confidant, and guide. They'll be there to celebrate your successes, big or small, and remind you that each step forward is a victory. Moreover, they understand that research and publishing can be emotionally draining, so they'll lend a supportive ear when you need to vent or discuss your fears. With an academic publishing coach, you’re hiring a professional and you're gaining a supportive ally who believes in your potential.

Gain unparalleled support from a professional academic publishing coach, as they expertly guide you through research publication with personalized expertise and encouragement.


The Power of Guidance and Support

Feeling lost in the vast ocean of academic publishing? That's where an academic publishing coach shines. They'll guide you through the maze of choosing the right journals, crafting compelling manuscripts, and navigating the peer-review process. With their support, you'll be equipped with a personalized roadmap, tailored to your unique research and goals. Trust me; having someone to lean on during those moments of doubt can make all the difference in the world.

Navigating the academic publishing world can be overwhelming, especially for early career academics. As you start this journey, it's natural to question your abilities and the significance of your research. Here's the truth: your work matters. Your ideas hold value, and the potential impact of your research is immense. An academic publishing coach will remind you of this, helping you find the motivation to persevere even when the going gets tough.

Overcoming Imposter Syndrome

Now, let's talk about the elephant in the room: imposter syndrome. It's that nagging feeling that your work isn't good enough, that you're a fraud, and that your peers are miles ahead of you. But guess what? Imposter syndrome affects most of us, and it's essential to acknowledge it. Your academic publishing coach will not only recognize this struggle but also provide strategies to overcome it.

Remember, imposter syndrome thrives on self-doubt and comparison. Your coach will encourage you to focus on your own growth and progress rather than constantly measuring yourself against others. They'll help you recognize your unique strengths and achievements, building the self-assurance needed to face any challenge that comes your way.

Empower yourself to overcome imposter syndrome and embrace growth with a coach by your side, handling the porential for rejection with resilience and determination.


Embracing Rejection as a Stepping Stone

Rejection. A word that sends shivers down the spines of many researchers. But listen, rejection is not a sign of failure; it happens to everyone and you can use it as an opportunity for growth. An academic publishing coach will help you cope with rejection, showing you that even the most accomplished scholars faced it at some point. They'll encourage you to learn from feedback, make improvements, and resubmit with newfound resilience. Remember, every rejection brings you closer to acceptance.

Rejection can be tough to handle, and it's natural to feel disheartened when your hard work doesn't get the recognition you hoped for. However, an academic publishing coach will remind you that rejection is not a reflection of your worth as a researcher. In fact, it's an integral part of the academic process, helping you refine your work and contribute to the collective body of knowledge.

Crafting Compelling Manuscripts

Writing a compelling manuscript can be daunting, but fear not! Your academic publishing coach is here to help you tell your research story with clarity and impact. They'll provide constructive feedback on your writing, ensuring that your ideas flow smoothly and your arguments resonate with readers. With their guidance, you'll learn the art of effective communication, a skill that extends beyond academia.

Your academic publishing coach understands that crafting a manuscript is not just about presenting data; it's about articulating an argument that communicates the significance of your research. They'll encourage you to hone your writing skills, transforming your work from a collection of findings into a compelling story that sparks interest and inspires others in your field.

Harness the power of expert mentorship to craft high-quality manuscripts and successfully navigate peer review.


Navigating the Peer-Review Process

Ah, peer review—the final frontier before publication. It's both a nerve-wracking and crucial part of the academic publishing journey. Your academic publishing coach will help you navigate this process by preparing you for potential challenges and addressing reviewers' comments strategically. Remember, this can be a learning experience, and each round of review brings you one step closer to the finish line.

Peer review can be both enlightening and challenging. While it offers valuable insights to enhance your research, it can also feel like a judgment of your capabilities. But with an academic publishing coach on your side, you'll learn to approach peer review with an open mind, viewing it as an opportunity to strengthen your work. They'll help you separate constructive criticism from harsh judgments and use feedback to refine your research further.

What Does a Coach Do That a Supervisor Doesn't?

While your academic supervisor plays a crucial role in guiding your research, an academic publishing coach brings distinctive advantages that complement and expand upon your supervisor-student relationship. An academic publishing coach specializes in the intricacies of the publishing process, providing expert guidance on selecting suitable journals, navigating peer review, and ensuring your work meets the high standards of academic publishing. Moreover, they offer an impartial perspective on your work, providing unbiased feedback and suggestions to help refine your manuscript.

Unlike supervisors with multiple responsibilities, an academic publishing coach's primary focus is on supporting your publishing goals. They provide dedicated, one-on-one guidance, working closely with you to overcome obstacles and improve your work. Furthermore, academic publishing coaches are well-versed in the emotional challenges that come with the process. They offer a safe space for you to discuss fears like imposter syndrome and rejection, things that you may not be comfortable about talking with your supervisor with, and providing encouragement and strategies to build resilience.

Academic publishing coaches can also assist with time management, helping you set realistic goals and deadlines and holding you accountable for meeting them. And, beyond your current research, an academic publishing coach offers holistic career support, helping you develop a long-term publication strategy and navigate the complexities of an academic career beyond the completion or your degree or your next career milestone. By combining the strengths of both your supervisor and coach, you have a powerful support system to navigate the academic publishing world with confidence and success.

While your supervisor has multiple roles and responsibilities, and is often time poor, a coach's primary focus is on supporting you academic and professional goals.


What Makes a Good Academic Publishing Coach?

As you embark on your search for an academic publishing coach, you may wonder what qualities and characteristics make a coach truly exceptional. Here are some key traits to look for when seeking out the perfect mentor to guide you through your publishing journey:

Experience and Expertise: A good academic publishing coach will have a track record of success in publishing their own research and assisting others in getting published. Look for someone with proven experience who understands the nuances of academic publishing and can provide valuable insights.
Empathy and Understanding: Publishing research can be an emotionally charged process, and a good coach will be empathetic to the challenges you face. They will understand the pressures and anxieties that come with academic publishing and offer emotional support and encouragement when you need it most. You will feel this in your initial consultations with them.

Effective Communication Skills: As a mentor, a good academic publishing coach should be an excellent communicator. They will be able to provide clear and constructive feedback on your work, helping you improve your writing and research while maintaining a positive and supportive tone. The foundation of this clarity should be established right from your initial communications with them.

Customized Guidance: Each researcher's journey is unique, and a good coach should recognize this. Look for a coach who tailors their guidance to your specific needs and goals, providing personalized strategies that align with your research aspirations.

Updated Knowledge: The academic publishing landscape is constantly evolving, with new trends and best practices emerging regularly. A good coach is updated with the latest developments and familiar with modern publishing platforms and strategies.

Positive Reputation and Reviews: When seeking an academic publishing coach, look for testimonials or reviews from past clients. A coach with a positive reputation and satisfied clients is a strong indicator of their ability to support and guide researchers effectively.

Passion for Mentorship: Above all, a good academic publishing coach will have a genuine passion for mentoring and helping others succeed. They will be committed to empowering researchers and celebrating their achievements throughout the publishing process. You will see evidence of this in their communications and your interactions with them.

Transparency and Authenticity: Academic publishing coaches take pride in being transparent and authentic individuals. They don't hide behind a faceless business name; instead, they are real people with genuine expertise and a passion for supporting researchers like you. When you work with an academic publishing coach, you know exactly who they are, and they're invested in forming a personal connection with you.

Find this helpful? Pin it on Pinterest. 



Publishing your research can be intimidating, but with an academic publishing coach by your side, you'll have a supportive mentor who understands your struggles and believes in your potential. So, let's break free from the chains of overwhelm and self-doubt. You are not alone in this pursuit of knowledge and publication. Embrace the guidance, support, and empowerment an academic publishing coach can offer, and let your research shine on the global stage.

Additional resources:

Unsure about whether you’d llke to hire a coach? Check out this article on 9 reasons to hire (or not hire) a coach.

Hi 👋. I’m Dr. Jayne Wilkins. Learn more about my coaching and consulting services here

Hi! I'm Dr Jayne Wilkins.

I'm a research scientist and academic publishing coach. I've been writing, reviewing, and editing academic publications for 12+ years.

In 2021, I achieved my long-time ambition to publish in Nature (woot woot 🎉).

Want to publish your research?

I can help you finish and submit that manuscript.

Learn More About Me

Grab the Free Guide

Learn how to submit a high-quality academic journal article the simpler and faster way.

You can get published and it doesn't have to be as hard as you think.

You have actually done A LOT of the hard work already!

In this guide, I show you how to leverage the work you've already done to create an awesome journal article that you will be proud of.

Send it to me!